intero
Back to blog
Incident Investigation

The Truck That Should Have Been Recovered

By Intero Team
An illustration of a low-profile truck raised on a single bottle jack at a motorway slip road, beside a job card with no line for the decision to recover the vehicle

On 2 August 2024, a commercial tyre fitter was sent to replace a blown-out tyre on a low-profile truck on the slip road at junction 7 of the M56, near Bowdon in Cheshire. He was 21 and had held his roadside licence for commercial tyres for less than four months.

He was working underneath the truck, which was raised on a bottle jack. The truck is understood to have slipped off the jack and landed on him. He died of head injuries.

On 3 November 2026, his employer, Halford Commercial Fleet Services Limited (formerly The Lodge Tyre Company Limited) of Redditch, was fined £600,000 at Warrington Magistrates' Court and ordered to pay £24,203 in costs. The company pleaded guilty to breaching Section 2(1) of the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974.

What the HSE investigation found

HSE's summary of the case sets out where the company fell short. Each failing points to a different control.

  • It had not properly assessed the risks of replacing a blown-out tyre on a low-profile vehicle.
  • It had not given employees suitable work instructions, including when a truck must be recovered instead of repaired at the roadside.
  • It did not monitor or supervise the young fitter to make sure he was working safely, despite his limited experience.

HSE Principal Inspector Laura Royales said the case "should serve to highlight to employers the importance of properly assessing the risks" of the work. HSE points employers to its guidance for motor vehicle repair, HSG261.

Reading it as an investigator

The immediate event is mechanical. A heavy vehicle came off a jack while a person was under it. A report could stop there and recommend that fitters never go under a vehicle supported only by a jack. That rule is right, and it would leave most of this case untouched.

The investigation is in the decisions made before the fitter arrived, and in what he had to work with when he got there.

The job was accepted as a roadside repair. A blown-out tyre on a low-profile truck is a specific situation. With the tyre gone, the axle sits lower, so there is less room to get a jack in and less margin if it shifts. Somebody, or some process, decided this was a roadside repair. The investigation should establish who made that call and what they knew about the vehicle and the location. It should also find out whether recovery to a workshop was ever considered.

There was no written point at which to stop. HSE found no suitable instruction on when a truck must be recovered. Without that line, the decision falls to the person at the vehicle, on a slip road, under time pressure from the customer and the traffic. An experienced fitter might refuse the job. A fitter four months into a roadside licence has less basis to say no and may not know that saying no is expected.

The risk assessment did not cover this task. Most tyre companies hold a general assessment for roadside work. The case suggests the specific combination here, a blowout on a low-profile vehicle, was not assessed on its own terms. A generic assessment tends to list the hazards everyone already knows and miss the ones that only appear in a particular configuration. When we read an assessment during an investigation, we check whether it describes the job as it was actually done that day.

Nobody was watching the new starter. Holding a licence shows that someone passed the training. It says little about how someone handles an awkward job with nobody checking. HSE found the fitter was not monitored or supervised despite his limited experience. The questions here are about how the company decided which jobs a newly licensed fitter could take on without supervision, and whether anyone reviewed how his first months were going.

The support under the vehicle. We would want to know what jack and what additional supports were on the van, whether they suited a low-profile truck with a blown tyre, and what the fitter had been trained to place under the vehicle before reaching beneath it. If the right equipment was not on the van, the instruction to use it could not have been followed.

Actions that would hold

When we write corrective actions for a case like this, we work up the hierarchy of controls and give each one an owner role and a date.

  • Write a recovery rule that names the vehicle types and tyre conditions where roadside repair is not allowed, and put the decision with the dispatcher before a fitter is sent.
  • Assess the blowout-on-low-profile task specifically, with the people who do it, and record the controls in the work instruction for that job.
  • Set out which jobs a newly licensed fitter may do alone, and for how long, with a named role responsible for checking in on solo jobs in that period.
  • Check that every roadside van carries supports suited to the heaviest and lowest vehicles its fitters attend, and make placing them before going under a vehicle a step on the job card.
  • Make it plain, in writing and in briefings, that a fitter who declines a roadside job and calls for recovery will be backed.

Each of these should close with evidence, such as the revised work instruction and the van equipment check. Six months on, look at how many jobs were sent for recovery under the new rule. A number close to zero is worth asking about.

Where Intero fits

Intero is built for this part of the job. An investigator describes what happened and adds the photos and statements they have. Intero asks the follow-up questions a lead investigator would, one at a time, including who decided the job could be done at the roadside and what the fitter had been told about when to stop.

In the analysis, each barrier is graded held, failed, partial, absent or unknown, and contributing factors are set out from the task through to the organisation. Every finding cites the evidence it rests on. If the risk assessment or the work instruction is in the organisation's library, Intero reads it with the case, so an assessment that never mentions low-profile vehicles shows up as part of the analysis.

Corrective actions are written up the hierarchy of controls and each traces to a finding. When an action is finished, its owner is asked by its horizon whether the fix held, and Intero looks through later cases for the same failure coming back.

You can see how a case runs in Intero and what the workspace includes.

A check worth doing this week

Pick one task your people do alone, away from site. Find the written point at which they are expected to stop and call for help, and ask your newest starter whether they know where it is.

If you want to see how Intero takes an incident like this from the first report to a fix that holds, book a demo.

---

Sources

Ready to see Intero in action?

Book a demo and see what AI agents can do for your safety operations.